Our Diaper by HealthyBaby Review: Is It Worth It
There's a diaper sitting in your cart right now, and you're wondering if "clean" means you'll be changing sheets at 2am.
I've been there. When my eldest was a newborn, I went down the rabbit hole of diaper ingredients, certifications, and whether any brand could actually deliver both safety and performance. What touches my daughters' skin matters deeply to me, but so does my sanity when we're on blowout number two and it’s not even 11am. I needed something I could trust that would also, you know, work.
We chose Our Diaper by HealthyBaby for both our girls. My eldest wore them from newborn through potty training, and my ten-month-old has been in them since day one.
Here's what I've learned after years of daily use, hundreds of overnight tests, and the kind of real-world performance checks that only parenthood provides.
Check out our roundup of the 3 best non-toxic diapers for an in depth comparison.
Why We Switched to HealthyBaby (And Never Looked Back)
When I was pregnant with my eldest, I was on a mission to find tried and true non-toxic baby products. Needless to say, this took me down many rabbit holes and late nights spent researching—which eventually brought me to diapers. And the more I researched conventional diapers, the more I realized they are filled with materials I'd never consciously choose: chlorine-bleached pulp, fragrances, lotions, and a whole list of ingredients that didn't need to be there. But here's the thing: I also needed diapers that actually worked. A "clean" diaper that leaks every night isn't a solution.
What made HealthyBaby different from the start:
EWG Verified certification (this matters because it's third-party verification of ingredient safety, not just marketing claims)
No chlorine bleaching, fragrances, lotions, or parabens (the stuff that irritates sensitive skin and has no business being there)
Plant-based materials that are sustainably sourced (they use FSC-certified fluff pulp and bio-based SAP)
Performance that actually holds up through overnight stretches and active toddler days
The EWG verification was huge for me. It meant an independent organization reviewed every single ingredient and manufacturing process to confirm it met incredibly strict health standards. When you're changing 8-10 diapers a day, that peace of mind isn't optional to me.
We have been using these diapers exclusively (minus an emergency pack when we’re a day shy of our next box arriving) for the last 4 years, and I haven't once considered changing it up. That should tell you something.
The Overnight Test (Where Most “Natural” Diapers Fail)
If a diaper can't make it through the night, I probably won’t buy it again.
This is where HealthyBaby really shines if you ask me. I have tested these diapers through countless overnight stretches with both girls, from newborn sleep to toddler 12-hour nights.
And they hold up. Consistently.
The absorbency comes from their dual-layer design: a plant-based top sheet that pulls moisture away from skin, and a bio-based super absorbent polymer (SAP) core that locks liquid in. That SAP is the key. HealthyBaby’s bio-based version performs just as well as conventional SAP without the petroleum-derived ingredients.
The fit matters here too. The stretchy sides and leg cuffs create an actual seal without the red marks you get from overly tight elastic. Fewer gaps means fewer leaks, even with sleepers that toss and turn.
What You’ll Notice About the Fit and Feel
The softness is immediately obvious. These don't have that crinkly, plasticky feel of conventional diapers. The plant-based inner lining feels closer to fabric, which makes sense when you're putting it against delicate newborn skin 24/7.
The sizing runs pretty true. We've used their entire size range between both our girls, and they run pretty true to their weight-based sizing recommendation. The only time I will size up earlier than the recommended weight is if I start noticing blow outs—when I size up they stop every time.
The stretchy side panels are genius. They move with your baby instead of restricting them, which matters more than you'd think when you've got a crawler or early walker testing their mobility. My ten-month-old is constantly on the move, and these stay put.
The leg cuffs actually prevent blowouts. The double leg cuffs create a barrier that contains messes without feeling too tight. We've also had dramatically fewer up-the-back incidents with HealthyBaby after their new and improved “blowout shield” design released in 2025.
Check out our favorite non-toxic alternatives to Aquaphor, and learn why we choose to avoid petroleum based ingredients.
The Ingredient Story (And Why EWG-Verification Matters)
Here's what most diaper brands won't tell you: conventional diapers can legally include a lot of questionable ingredients without listing them.
Fragrances, lotions, dyes, chlorine bleach, phthalates, and parabens show up in many mainstream diapers. Some use SAP derived from petroleum. Others add "skin-soothing" lotions that can actually irritate sensitive skin. The FDA doesn't regulate diapers the way it does other baby products, so brands have a lot of leeway.
HealthyBaby took a different approach:
Every material is disclosed and verified by the Environmental Working Group
The fluff pulp is FSC-certified (responsibly sourced and processed without chlorine bleaching)
The SAP is bio-based, derived from plant sources instead of petroleum
The top sheet is made from plant-based materials that are gentle and breathable
Zero added fragrances, lotions, latex, or harsh chemicals
The EWG Verified certification isn't just a badge. It means HealthyBaby submitted their full ingredient list, manufacturing processes, and supply chain for review. EWG scientists evaluated every component against their strict health standards. For a product that's against your baby's skin for potentially two-three years straight, that transparency matters.
I've read the ingredient lists on conventional diaper packages. Most don't even list ingredients. HealthyBaby publishes theirs openly, which tells you everything about their confidence in what they're using.
There's also no wetness indicator (that yellow line that turns blue when the diaper is wet), which I am so thankful for. If you ask me, the extra chemicals used for this feature are unnecessary—I can tell if my daughters diaper is wet by looking at it the majority of the time, and if I’m ever unsure I simply feel it—easy peasy.
Day-to-Day Performance With an Active Baby
My ten-month-old is in that phase where she's crawling, pulling up, and getting into everything.
Diapers take a beating during this stage. They need to stay put during diaper changes (which are now wrestling matches), hold up through hours of movement, and not sag or bunch when she's on the go. HealthyBaby handles it all without the constant readjusting.
What I notice during busy days:
These diapers maintain their shape even when fully wet. There's no saggy-diaper waddle happening, which means better comfort for her. The absorbent core distributes wetness evenly instead of creating that heavy front-loaded feeling.
The fasteners are strong and repositionable. I can adjust the fit multiple times during a change without the tabs losing their stick. This seems minor until you're trying to get the fit just right on a wiggling baby.
The materials breathe better than plastic-heavy diapers. My daughter very seldom has any redness, and has never had a severe diaper rash. Better airflow and cleaner ingredients makes a real difference.
The Sustainability Piece (Without the Greenwashing)
Let's be honest about diapers and sustainability.
Disposable diapers are not a zero-waste solution. Anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something. But there are meaningful differences in how diapers are made, what they're made from, and how companies approach environmental impact.
HealthyBaby makes choices that reduce harm without sacrificing performance. The plant-based materials are renewable and sustainably sourced. The manufacturing process avoids chlorine bleaching, which prevents toxic dioxin discharge into waterways. The packaging is minimal and made from recycled materials.
Is it perfect? No. These still go to landfills. But if you simply don't have the capacity for cloth, choosing a disposable diaper with cleaner ingredients and more responsible sourcing is the better option.
I appreciate that HealthyBaby doesn't pretend they've solved the disposable diaper waste problem. They're just making the most responsible disposable option they can, with baby’s health and safety front and center.
To learn more about the impact disposable diapers have on the environment, read this informative article on the World Economic Forum.
Have you ever chosen a product that seemed non-toxic, only to discover it had the same ingredients you were trying to avoid? You’re not alone — check out my article Greenwashing 101: How to Spot It and Avoid Being Misled
What You Should Know About Pricing
HealthyBaby diapers do cost more than conventional store brands.
You're looking at roughly 35-45 cents per diaper depending on size and whether you subscribe, compared to 20-25 cents for conventional brands. Over the two to three years your child is in diapers, that difference adds up.
Here's how I think about the cost:
You're paying for independently verified clean ingredients, better materials, and a company that transparently shares what goes into their products. You're also getting diapers that perform as well or better than conventional options, which means fewer leaks, less laundry, and fewer middle-of-the-night sheet changes.
The subscription option does bring the cost down a bit. HealthyBaby offers flexible delivery schedules, and you can adjust or skip shipments easily. We've been on a subscription since the beginning, and it's been really convenient. We have run out a time or two—when this happens I’ll usually buy a small pack of another “clean” diaper that’s on the shelves in one of our local stores to get us by until our box arrives.
If your budget is tight and choosing healthy materials is a priority to you, it may be worth considering organic cloth diapers. This may seem daunting at first, but I know many mamas that have used them with all their babies—once they find their routine, it’s as easy as anything else. And it really is the most cost effective diapering solution.
The Real Limitations Worth Knowing
No diaper is perfect for every baby or every situation.
HealthyBaby works best for parents who prioritize ingredient safety. If your primary concern is rock-bottom pricing and you're not worried about what's in your diapers, there are cheaper options that will technically do the job.
The subscription model is the most cost-effective way to buy these, but it requires a bit of planning. If you prefer grabbing diapers during your weekly grocery run, you'll need to adjust your routine since these aren't in most big-box stores.
They're not as widely available as mainstream brands. You won't find them at every grocery store (though I have seen them in some Target stores), which means you need to stay on top of your supply. We rarely run out because of the subscription.
Who Should Choose HealthyBaby Diapers
Our Diaper by HealthyBaby may be the right diapers for you if:
You're a parent who wants clean, verified ingredients without sacrificing performance.
You care deeply about what touches your baby's skin nearly 24/7.
You're willing to invest a bit more in a product that's been independently verified for safety.
You value transparency from companies and want to know exactly what you're buying.
They're also ideal if your baby has sensitive skin or you've dealt with recurring diaper rash. The cleaner ingredient list and better breathability make a noticeable difference for babies who react to fragrances, lotions, or harsh materials.
You'll be especially happy with these if:
You need reliable overnight protection that doesn't leak
You want the convenience of disposables with cleaner ingredients
You appreciate companies that publish full ingredient lists and seek third-party verification
You're looking for diapers that perform as well as conventional brands while being better for your baby
You want to reduce your family's exposure to unnecessary chemicals
If you're purely budget-shopping or you're someone who cycles through multiple brands based on sales, these might not be your match. And if your baby thrives in whatever diaper you choose and you're happy with your current option, there's no need to switch just for the sake of it.
But if you've been searching for diapers that align with how you're trying to raise your family (fewer toxins, more transparency, better ingredients), HealthyBaby is the brand that delivers on those promises while actually working in real life.
Final Thoughts
After using these exclusively with both my daughters through thousands of diaper changes, late nights, blowouts, and everything in between, I trust them completely. That's not something I say lightly about products that are this integral to daily life with babies.
What touches your baby's skin matters, and these are diapers you can feel good about using every single day. We made the choice to use HealthyBaby diapers for our girls, and years later, I'd make the same choice again without hesitation.
Latest on the blog
