Non-Toxic Art Supplies for Valentine Crafts (Kid-Safe & Mom-Approved)

Valentine crafts are one of the simplest ways to add warmth to the middle of winter. Kids get busy creating tiny cards for friends, gluing paper hearts to envelopes, and experimenting with shades of pink and red. It’s sweet, a little messy, and one of those seasonal activities that doesn’t need to be complicated.

The part that often complicates it is the art supplies themselves. Many mainstream craft aisles are filled with petroleum-based crayons, synthetic dyes, fragrances, solvent-heavy glues, and glitter that sheds microplastics everywhere. The good news: there are non-toxic, kid-safe, and environmentally friendlier options that work beautifully for Valentine’s crafts. With a few thoughtful swaps, you can keep holiday art-making colorful and engaging without the fumes, synthetic fragrances, or plastic glitter fallout.

Below are the categories we reach for most, the brands that have held up well in our home, and a few notes on what actually matters when choosing art supplies for kids.

Check out our Ultimate Guide to Non-Toxic Valentine Gifts for Kids (That Aren’t Candy)

Why Choose Non-Toxic Art Supplies for Kids

Children explore through touch. For toddlers and preschoolers especially, crafting is a full sensory experience: hands in paint, glue on fingertips, IYKYK. Because so much of early crafting is body-based, avoiding unnecessary chemicals where we can is an easy way to support their developing systems.

Choosing non-toxic art supplies also reduces exposure to:

• heavy metals and petroleum byproducts

• endocrine-disrupting chemicals

• artificial fragrances and solvents

• microplastics and unnecessary synthetics

Many of the better brands carry certifications such as ASTM D-4236, CE, AP Certified, or FSC for wood and paper. These aren’t perfect guarantees, but they do help filter out some of the worst offenders and signal that a company has considered safety beyond basic compliance.

Ingredients and Materials Worth Avoiding

Perfection isn’t the goal, but knowing what’s common in conventional art supplies helps you shop with less overwhelm. Ingredients and materials we generally skip include:

• petroleum wax crayons

• artificial dyes such as Red 40 and Blue 1

• solvent-based markers

• synthetic fragrance

• polyvinyl glitter

• acrylic craft paints formulated for adult use

• vinyl stickers and PVC components

• PFAS-treated papers marketed as “waterproof” or “smudge-proof”

Again, this isn’t about rigid rules. It’s about choosing safer baselines for the items kids handle most during craft time.

Non-Toxic Art Supplies for Valentine Crafts

These categories work particularly well for handmade cards, envelopes, small gifts, keepsakes, and afternoon art trays.

1. Beeswax Crayons and Blocks

Beeswax crayons are naturally firmer, glide smoothly across paper, and last significantly longer than petroleum crayons. Blocks are especially helpful for toddlers who are still learning how to hold writing tools.

Recommended brands:

• Stockmar Beeswax Crayons — richly pigmented and long-lasting

• Honeysticks Pure Beeswax Crayons — chunky, durable, toddler-friendly

• Filana Beeswax Crayons — AP certified

These crayons also resist snapping in half when kids press a little too enthusiastically, which is a small but meaningful parenting win.

2. Natural Watercolor Paints

Plant and mineral-based watercolors work beautifully for Valentine’s projects, especially when layering pinks, purples, and reds.

Recommended brands:

• Natural Earth Paint Watercolor Kit — mineral pigments, excellent color

• ÖkoNorm Watercolor Set — EN-71 certified, vibrant shades

• Honeysticks Watercolors — washable and toddler-friendly (this is the set we use with my 4-year-old)

3. Non-Toxic Finger Paints

Finger painting is one of the easiest toddler art setups for Valentine’s Day. For kids who like sensory play, the tactile aspect often keeps them engaged longer than crayons or markers.

Recommended brands:

• Eco-Kids Finger Paint — colored with fruits and veggies

• ÖkoNorm Finger Paint Set — non-toxic and EU-certified

4. Plant-Based Glue Sticks and Pastes

Valentine crafting tends to be heavy on gluing. Many conventional glue sticks contain solvents or artificial fragrances; these alternatives are gentler and still work well.

Recommended brands:

• ÖkoNorm Glue Stick — rice-based, solvent-free

Toddlers especially love glue pasting, and these formulas avoid the harsh chemical smell that shows up with some craft glues.

5. Natural Modeling Dough and Clay

For shaping hearts, pressing stamps, creating impressions, or making small keepsakes, doughs and clays offer more dimension than paper crafts alone.

Recommended brands:

• Eco-Dough — plant dyes with a soft, squishy texture

Homemade dough tinted with small amounts of beet powder or raspberry powder is also lovely for Valentine’s Day.

6. Kid-Safe Scissors

If your child is ready, cutting paper hearts is essentially a Valentine rite of passage. Scissors designed for small hands help build grip and confidence without frustration.

Recommended brands:

• Maped Koopy Spring Scissors — excellent for beginners

• Westcott Blunt Kids Scissors — simple and inexpensive

7. Sustainable Paper, Cards, and Envelopes

Look for paper that is FSC-certified, recycled, uncoated, and heavier weight if you plan to paint on it.

Recommended options:

• Tru-Ray Construction Paper — Sustainable Forestry Initiative certified sourcing, made in the USA

8. Wooden Stamps and Craft Tools

Stamps and simple wooden tools add interest without bringing in vinyl stickers or plastic glitter.

Tools worth keeping in rotation:

• mini stampers

• wooden rolling pins

• nature stamps (leaves, flowers, branches)

• heart-shaped cutters

Recommended brands:

• Melissa & Doug Wooden Stamp Sets — washable ink (it’s not perfect, but better than most)

9. Biodegradable Glitter Alternatives

Traditional glitter is essentially microplastic, making clean-up difficult and environmentally problematic. Cellulose, mica, and plant-based glitters offer similar sparkle without the long-term shedding.

Recommended brand:

• Hemway Eco Friendly Biodegradable Glitter — made from plant-based materials

This is an especially good swap for homemade cards and sensory bins.

Sustainable Crafting Tips for Valentine’s Day

A few simple habits make seasonal crafting lower waste without losing the charm:

• save shipping cardboard for card-making

• repurpose glass jars for brush water or paint

• punch hearts from old watercolor paintings

• choose cloth ribbons over plastic

• compost paper scraps when possible

• add dried rose petals or leaves for nature texture

• prioritize keepsakes over disposable crafts

Toddlers and preschoolers rarely need elaborate projects. A stack of upcycled paper, a glue stick, and a single wooden stamp can keep them content.

Final Thoughts: Connection Over Perfection

The heart of Valentine crafting with kids isn’t about producing Pinterest-level cards or matching perfection. It’s about the small rituals of sitting together at the table, sharing materials, and making something by hand for someone they love.

Slow, simple, and safe is more than enough.

Latest on the blog